Probationary Dismissal

March 1, 2021

Court of Appeal Overturns Decision on Probation Dismissals


On the 16th February 2021 the Court of Appeal issued their decision concerning Probation dismissals, in O'Donovan -v- Over C Technology Limited & Anor IECA 37 [2021] and overturned a High Court decision, providing much need clarification in relation the law and dismissal during probationary periods.


The High Court Hearing granted injunctive relief and held employees right to fair procedures were “not confined to cases where the dismissal was by reason of an allegation of misconduct" but also applied to cases of “poor performance" dismissals. This was done despite the fact that Mr O’Donovan was still well within his contractual probationary period.


The Court of Appeal held the High Court failed to give adequate weight to fact that Mr O’Donovan’s dismissal occurred during the probation period. In doing so the CoA stated that during the period of probation, all parties must be free to terminate the employment for any or no reason and, importantly, a dismissal for poor performance does not attract the employees right to natural justice and fair procedures, whereas dismissal for misconduct would.

This case highlights the need for employers to conduct adequate performance reviews of new employees during the probationary period, and to act on such issues in a timely fashion.


It should be born in mind that often performance issues and misconduct issues are often closely related and therefore may be difficult to distinguish between the two. Further employees dismissed during probation may still have redress under the Industrial Relations Acts, and the Unfair Dismissals Act, in certain specified cases such as for trade Union Activity, Equality grounds or for having made a protected disclosure.



Where an employer is seeking to dismiss an employee even during probation it is advised they seek professional advice before doing so.


Case Linkhttps://www.courts.ie/acc/alfresco/407a36b1-8660-4181-b6b8-9387a6b1b84c/2021_IECA_37%20(Unapproved).pdf/pdf#view=fitH


WRC Upholds Constructive Dismissal and Protected Disclosure Complaints
By Amy Vickers June 4, 2026
Health and safety concerns, deteriorating workplace relationships and poor record keeping create significant exposure for employers
WRC Criticises Employer Conduct, Workplace Practices and AI Generated Submission
By Amy Vickers June 4, 2026
WRC decision highlights that seemingly casual comments, compliance failures, and the careless use of AI material can all contribute to legal liability
Is workplace conflict increasing, or are employees less tolerant?
By Amy Vickers June 4, 2026
Are workplaces actually becoming more difficult or are employees simply becoming far less willing to tolerate behaviour that previous generations may have ignored
How Long Is Too Long? The Cost of Delayed Recruitment Decisions
By Amy Vickers June 4, 2026
Many employers would be surprised to learn how often good candidates are lost because a recruitment process takes too long.
By Tara Daly May 19, 2026
Irish employers are increasingly turning to international hiring as a solution to ongoing skills shortages. This trend is particularly evident in sectors where local talent is limited and demand continues to grow. Why employers are looking overseas Common drivers include: • Difficulty filling specialist roles locally • Business expansion and growth • Increased competition for talent International hiring can provide access to a wider talent pool and support long-term workforce planning. The challenge While the opportunity is clear, the employment permit process can be complex. Employers often underestimate: • The level of detail required in applications • The importance of aligning with eligibility criteria • The potential for delays or refusals Where the process is not managed properly, the impact can be significant. Roles remain open for longer, business plans are affected, and onboarding timelines move further out than expected. Getting it right A structured and informed approach is essential. This includes: • Understanding the appropriate permit type • Ensuring the role meets eligibility requirements • Preparing a clear and robust application Where employers take the time to position the role properly and support the application with strong documentation, the process is far more likely to run smoothly. Key takeaway for employers International hiring can be a highly effective solution, but only where the permit process is managed correctly. Approached properly, it enables businesses to secure the talent they need to grow and succeed with greater certainty and less disruption. If you would like advice or support with the employment permit process, our team would be happy to assist. info@mssthehrpeople.ie | 01 887 0690
By Tara Daly May 13, 2026
A common approach we encounter is employers submitting an employment permit application and waiting to see what happens. While understandable, this approach carries significant risk. Why this approach falls short Employment permit applications are not a simple box-ticking exercise. Each application is assessed based on: • Eligibility • Justification • Alignment with current criteria If any of these elements are unclear or insufficient, the application may be delayed or refused. The impact of getting it wrong Where an application is unsuccessful: • Timelines are extended • Recruitment plans are disrupted • Candidates may withdraw In a competitive hiring market, these delays can have a real impact on the business. A role can remain unfilled for longer than expected, existing teams can come under pressure, and a strong candidate may choose another opportunity. A better approach Employers should approach permit applications as a structured process, focusing on: • Clear alignment with eligibility criteria • Strong and accurate role definition • Comprehensive supporting rationale It is far more effective to identify and address risk areas before submission than to deal with the consequences of delay or refusal later. Key takeaway for employers Submitting an application without fully assessing the risks can lead to avoidable delays. A well-prepared application significantly improves the likelihood of a successful outcome and gives the employer greater confidence throughout the process. If you’re planning an overseas hire or facing delays, we’re happy to talk it through. info@mssthehrpeople.ie | 01 887 0690
WRC awards €15,000 after employee kept on “specific purpose” contract for 10 years
By Amy Vickers May 7, 2026
A recent WRC decision is a very important reminder to employers that long running “specific purpose” and fixed term arrangements can create significant risk
Workplace Bullying, Harassment and Sexual Harassment Claims Are Rising
By Amy Vickers May 7, 2026
Increase in complaints relating to bullying, harassment, and sexual harassment and the complexity and escalation of these cases.
Supporting Employees Through Pregnancy Loss
By Amy Vickers May 7, 2026
Pregnancy loss is a deeply personal experience. For employers, these situations can be equally challenging because of the uncertainty around it.
Psychological Illness Now the Leading Cause of Income Protection Claims in Ireland
By Amy Vickers May 7, 2026
significant shift in workplace health trends, with psychological illness now the most common cause of income protection claims in Ireland.