Labour Court Doubles Compensation to €104,000 in Unfair Dismissal Case Involving Overseas Email Access

April 9, 2026

ADJ-00045339


A recent decision involving Dublin Business School highlights how compensation awards can significantly increase on appeal, with the Labour Court more than doubling a Workplace Relations Commission (WRC) award in an unfair dismissal case.


Background

The employee, a lecturer, was dismissed in February 2023 following a disciplinary process which found him guilty of gross misconduct. The issue arose after he accessed his work email while visiting Iran, a country the employer had designated as “prohibited” for system access.


The lecturer had travelled abroad to attend a family funeral. Despite being instructed not to access the system, the employer determined that doing so constituted a serious breach of policy and proceeded to dismiss him.


Importantly, the employer later conceded, both at the WRC and on appeal, that the dismissal was unfair.


WRC Decision: €53,000 Award

At first instance, the WRC focused solely on redress, as liability was no longer in dispute.

The Adjudication Officer considered:


  • The complainant’s financial loss, including his earnings (which averaged approximately €91,000 due to additional work beyond his base salary).
  • His efforts to mitigate loss, including job applications and periods of part-time work.
  • Personal circumstances affecting his ability to secure new employment, including bereavement and family difficulties.
  • The impact of the dismissal on his reputation within a relatively small professional community.


While acknowledging the significant impact of the dismissal, the WRC found that the employee’s mitigation efforts were not fully sufficient.


Taking all factors into account, compensation of €53,000 was awarded.


Labour Court Appeal: Award Increased to €104,000

The lecturer appealed the adequacy of the compensation to the Labour Court.


On appeal, the Court reassessed:

  • The scale and duration of financial loss.
  • The employee’s evidence that he had made over 100 job applications.
  • The reputational damage arising from the dismissal.
  • The fact that he had only secured lower-paid, temporary lecturing roles since his dismissal.


The Court also noted:

  • No evidence was presented by the employer to justify the dismissal.
  • No persuasive evidence that the employee contributed to his dismissal.
  • While mitigation efforts were made, they were not considered fully comprehensive.


Based on an annual income of approximately €91,000, the Court noted that the statutory maximum award could exceed €180,000.


Balancing all factors, the Labour Court concluded that a €104,000 award was “just and equitable”, effectively doubling the WRC award.


Key Takeaways for Employers

This case serves as an important reminder of several key principles:


1.   Even admitted unfair dismissals can carry escalating financial risk. An initial award may not be the final exposure, appeals can significantly increase compensation.


2.   Gross misconduct thresholds must be carefully assessed. Dismissal for a single act, particularly in unusual or sensitive personal circumstances, may not always be proportionate.


3.   Mitigation arguments matter, but are not decisive. While employees must make reasonable efforts to find work, imperfect mitigation will not eliminate employer liability.


4.   Reputation damage can influence compensation. Particularly in niche sectors, dismissal can have longer-term career consequences which tribunals will consider.


5.   Evidence at the appeal stage is critical. The absence of employer evidence at Labour Court level weakened the respondent’s position significantly.


If you require help navigating a disciplinary matter or require representation at the WRC or Labour Court please do not hesitate to contact MSS The HR People. Phone: 018870690, Email: info@mssthehrpeople.ie, visit our website

WRC Awards €25,000 for Age Discrimination Following Mandatory Retirement
By Amanda Scully • November 10, 2026
Retirement arrangements must be clearly communicated, properly documented and objectively justified in accordance with Irish employment equality legislation.
WRC Awards €25,000 After Employee Dismissed Following Miscarriage
By Amanda Scully • November 10, 2026
Risks for employers when managing performance and probation where pregnancy or pregnancy related circumstances are involved
Mental Health in the Workplace: 6 Common Employer Mistakes That Can Lead to WRC Claims
By Amanda Scully • November 10, 2026
Employers have a responsibility to take employee health and safety seriously, including mental health.
Many Employees Not Using Their Annual Leave: What Employers Need to Know
By Amanda Scully • November 10, 2026
Employees not using their full annual leave entitlement but under the organisation of working time act employers have an obligation to make sure employees use it
Employment Contracts: A Comprehensive Guide for Irish Employers
By Tara Daly • October 28, 2026
Ensure your contracts are compliant with Irish employment legislation or purchase contract todays and purchase employee handbook
Adverse Weather Conditions - Navigating Work
By Amy Vickers • October 21, 2026
Navigating work situations when adverse weather causes disruption
Budget 2027: Minimum Wage 2027
By Amanda Scully • October 13, 2026
Changes for minimum wage 2027, employer PRSI, income tax and USC, with continued supports for small and medium sized businesses
WRC Inspections: Is Your Business Ready?
By Amanda Scully • October 8, 2026
WRC inspections are an important part of ensuring employers across Ireland are complying with their employment law obligations, are you compliant.
Planning Your 2027 Recruitment: Why Employers Should Start Now
By Amanda Scully • October 8, 2026
Recruitment is often something companies think about when a vacancy arises, now is a good time to start looking ahead to your recruitment needs for 2027.
WRC Finds Employee Was Penalised After Raising Concerns About Pay and Tax
By Amanda Scully • October 8, 2026
Understand what may constitute a protected disclosure and the risks for employers when an employee raises concerns about potential breaches of employment