Interesting and Notable Cases of 2022

February 13, 2023

Interesting and Notable Cases of 2022



For employers and HR professionals, 2022 has been a year of significant changes and major developments in many aspects of employment Law, and the case law reflects this. In 2022 we saw new legislation enhance employee rights and the WRC awarding a claimant the largest award in its history and, in two other cases, made it clear that it was not afraid of awarding six figures’ sums when deemed appropriate.


Below, we have reviewed some of the more important and noteworthy decisions from the WRC and in Employment Law;


6 Figure Awards


A Sales Executive v A Software Company


In June 2022, the WRC awarded the largest sum ever for an unfair dismissal case. The claimant was awarded €329,199.00. The Employee was dismissed on the grounds of serious misconduct, following bullying allegations.


The WRC found that despite the fact that there was an employee handbook in place, the employee received no formal warning in line with the process set out in the handbook. In short, the company failed to follow the terms of the handbook and its own procedures.

The award was high as it took the employee 22 months to find alternative employment, partially due to the “niche sector” and partially due to the reason for the dismissal.


This should be a lesson to employers that ensuring adherence to their existing policies and procedures is crucial.


https://www.workplacerelations.ie/en/cases/2022/april/adj-00027573.html


Walsh v Econocom Digital Finance


Here the WRC awarded €120,000.00 for an Unfair Dismissal. Whilst the Adjudicator accepted that it was a genuine redundancy situation and that any appeal would likely be a futile exercise, it found that no credible explanation was given for the decision of the managers not to engage with the Complainant to identify a suitable alternative role or to extend his notice period so that he could find another job.


This serves as a reminder to employers of the importance of consulting with employees in relation to any reasonable alternative roles that may be available should their existing roles be declared redundant.


https://www.workplacerelations.ie/en/cases/2022/january/adj-00029093.html


Reddy v Ardbrook Redundancy ADJ 29419


In this case, the WRC awarded a manager €119,000.00 in an award for unfair dismissal, after finding that the employee was dismissed “under the cloak of Redundancy”. Further, the WRC found that there were procedural errors in the redundancy process as admitted by the company.


While the facts in this case vary, it shows that the WRC is not afraid of making substantial awards where there are procedural flaws in the dismissal of an employee.


https://www.workplacerelations.ie/en/cases/2022/january/adj-00029419.html


Data Protection Commissioner v Doolin [2022] IECA 117.


In 2022 the Court of Appeal considered the use of CCTV footage in internal disciplinary investigations. The Court of Appeal reaffirmed the dangers of the use of CCTV for employee monitoring and using CCTV for a purpose not specified by the employer to the employees.


The Court held that the Data Protection Commission (DPC) was incorrect to state that the CCTV footage was only processed when it was viewed by the employer. In fact, it found it was processed three times:

a)   it was initially processed when it was recorded;

b)   it was then processed once more when it was accessed by the investigators; and

c)   processing then occurred a third time when data of dates and times were set out in the final disciplinary report.


Ultimately the Court felt that the concept of notifying the employee of the purpose for which CCTV was being used was central to the case, and data can only be used for the purpose of processing at or before the time the data (CCTV) was collected, and the purpose cannot be remedied after the fact.


This is a reaffirmation and strong reminder that businesses need to have effective and compliant data protection policies and CCTV policies, which clearly identify how and when such data can be used.


https://www.courts.ie/view/judgments/6ca61b58-4057-4572-99f5-5a93146d0bb6/66b46093-5fd1-4fff-86dd-11703bff3952/2022_IECA_117.pdf/pdf


Keating V Camfil


Finally, in an interesting case, the WRC found that an employee, who was dismissed for being on holiday while being unable to work due to a bad back, lost her unfair dismissal case. However, she was awarded €3,900.00 for withheld annual leave and public holiday entitlements.


This is an important case; in that it clearly shows that an employee’s annual leave and public holiday entitlements are theirs and cannot be withheld by the employer for any reason.


https://www.workplacerelations.ie/en/cases/2022/august/adj-00030501.html


As always, at MSS - the HR People we are here to advise you on any of the matters outlined in this update.



Contact Us

New paragraph

   

By Tara Daly June 13, 2025
When “Better Than Statutory” Really Matters
What Irish Employers Need to Know About the Employment (Contractual Retirement Ages) Bill 2025
By Tara Daly June 12, 2025
What Irish Employers Need to Know About the Employment (Contractual Retirement Ages) Bill 2025. The Irish government has taken a significant step forward in reshaping retirement policy in the workplace with the publication of the Employment (Contractual Retirement Ages) Bill 2025. Once enacted, this legislation will introduce a new employment right, allowing, but not obliging, employees to remain in work until they reach the State Pension age.
: A Practical Guide for Employers
By Tara Daly June 12, 2025
A Practical Guide for Employers. In today's dynamic workforce, fixed-term and specified purpose contracts have become a common feature across various sectors in Ireland. Whether it's covering maternity leave, managing seasonal workloads, or executing specific projects, these contracts offer flexibility to employers and opportunities to employees. However, it's crucial to understand the legal framework governing these contracts to ensure compliance and protect the rights of all parties involved.
First WRC Award in Right to Request Remote Working claim
By Tara Daly June 12, 2025
The Workplace Relations Commission (WRC) has issued its first award under the Work Life Balance and Miscellaneous Provisions Act 2023, and it's a timely reminder for employers across Ireland. Although multiple claims had previously been submitted to the WRC under this legislation, all were unsuccessful prior to this case.
How to Calculate Statutory Annual Leave in Ireland
By Tara Daly June 12, 2025
Annual leave entitlements are a fundamental part of every employee’s contract. But when it comes to calculating statutory annual leave, particularly for employees with variable hours, many employers are unsure of the rules
By Tara Daly May 13, 2025
What does this mean for Irish and UK Employers
By Tara Daly May 13, 2025
What Employers Need to Know
By Tara Daly May 13, 2025
A Temporary Relief for SMEs or Just Delayed Pressure?
Auto-Enrolment Delayed
By Tara Daly May 13, 2025
Auto-Enrolment Delayed. Why is there delays? when?
By Tara Daly May 1, 2025
At MSS The HR People, we often get asked, “What exactly is HR advice?” It’s a great question — and one that cuts right to the heart of what we do every day for our clients. What Is HR Advice? HR advice is professional guidance provided to employers and managers on how to manage people in the workplace. Whether you run a small business with a handful of employees or are a scaling SME with growing staffing needs, the right HR support can help you stay compliant, avoid costly mistakes, and build a high-performing team.  In this blog, we’ll break down what HR employer advice actually is, how to know when you need it, and what your options are for getting the right professional HR support - without hiring a full-time HR manager. It spans everything from recruitment and onboarding to performance management, employee relations, and employment law compliance. Good HR advice helps businesses stay compliant, make informed decisions, and avoid costly pitfalls. But more than that — great HR advice is practical, proactive, and tailored to your business needs. Types of HR Advice We Offer At MSS The HR People, we support clients with a broad range of HR issues. These include: Employee Relations – Managing grievances, disciplinaries, investigations, or conflict resolution. Performance & Conduct – Supporting managers with underperformance, absenteeism, or behavioural issues. Contracts & Policies – Drafting or reviewing contracts, handbooks, and HR policies to ensure legal compliance. HR Compliance – Advising on employment law updates and how to implement them in your business. Probation & Onboarding – Helping clients manage probation periods effectively and set new hires up for success. Redundancy & Restructuring – Providing guidance through challenging workforce changes. Everyday Queries – Whether it’s questions on annual leave entitlements, sick pay, or flexible working, no query is too small. What Do Clients Typically Contact Us For? Clients contact us when they: Need a second opinion or a clear interpretation of employment legislation. Are unsure how to approach a difficult conversation or situation. Want to ensure their HR practices are fair, consistent, and legally compliant. Are looking to reduce HR risk while improving employee engagement and culture. Have already worked out an approach and just want quick validation or a sounding board before taking action. Simply want quick, professional HR advice on tap. Why Is HR Advice Important? Irish employment legislation is constantly evolving - with updates to minimum wage, statutory sick pay entitlements, and gender pay gap reporting introduced so far this year – and it’s only April! Business owners are expected to keep up with these changes, ensure compliance, and handle any workplace issues appropriately. Getting it wrong can be costly. A poorly handled disciplinary, a missing contract, or a misstep during a redundancy process can result in: WRC (Workplace Relations Commission) complaints Penalties or fines Damaged reputation Low staff morale or high turnover HR advice ensures you don’t fall into these traps. Instead, it gives you the confidence to act decisively and fairly - whether you’re growing your team or managing a tough issue. How Do I Know If I Need HR Advice? Here are some of the most common signs that your business needs HR support: 1. You're Hiring or Growing Your Team Bringing on employees is a big step for any business. It’s important to have compliant employment contracts, solid onboarding processes, and clear expectations. If you're unsure where to start or want to do things right from the get-go, expert HR advice can set you up for success. 2. You Don’t Have Written HR Policies All employers should have clear policies in place such as an employee handbook, disciplinary procedure, grievance policy, absence management, and remote working guidelines. If you don’t have these in writing (or haven’t updated them in years), it’s time to get professional help. 3. You're Dealing with a Staff Issue If you're facing challenges like persistent absenteeism, underperformance, or conflict between employees, it can be difficult to know how to handle it correctly. HR consultants can guide you through fair processes, help you document everything, and reduce your legal risk. 4. You Want to Avoid a WRC Complaint If you’ve had a close call - or just want to make sure you're doing everything by the book - getting HR advice is a proactive way to protect your business and reduce the chance of ending up in front of the WRC. Not all HR support is created equal however, so it’s important to work with a provider who delivers straightforward, practical advice tailored to your business size and sector. The best HR Advice providers take a proactive (not just reactive) approach, providing practical tools like compliant templates, letters, and policies, along with training or coaching for managers when needed. Depending on your needs and budget, there are several ways to access HR support. One-off HR advice is ideal if you're dealing with a specific issue, such as a staff dispute or restructure, and need expert guidance. An HR health check or audit is a smart starting point if you're unsure about compliance, offering a full review of your contracts, policies, and procedures with a clear action plan. For ongoing peace of mind, many businesses opt for outsourced HR support, giving them access to expert advice without the cost of hiring in-house. Retained HR consultancy offers regular, tailored support for businesses that are growing or managing complex employee relations on an ongoing basis. How to Get Started Start by assessing your current situation. Do you need help with a one-off issue, like a disciplinary meeting? Or are you looking for ongoing HR support for your business? Make a list of your concerns: lack of policies, recruitment headaches, managing performance, or dealing with absence or sick leave. The more clarity you have, the more focused your consultant’s advice can be. Ready to Take the Headache Out of HR? As we have identified, getting HR advice isn’t just about avoiding fines - it’s about creating a better place to work, retaining great talent, and freeing you up to focus on growing your business. At MSS – The HR People, we offer expert HR support for employers that’s clear, compliant, and commercial. From one-off consultations to fully outsourced solutions, we’re here to help you get HR right. Ready to get started or just want to have a quick chat about your HR challenges? Contact us today to arrange a free discovery call. Whether you’re an SME owner, a manager navigating a tricky staff issue, or an organisation looking to strengthen your HR framework, MSS The HR People is here to help.
More Posts