Employee Compensated €60,000 for Discriminatory Dismissal

September 30, 2024

In a landmark ruling, the Chadwicks Group, a prominent builders' merchanting business, has been ordered to pay €60,000 in compensation to a long-serving employee who faced discrimination due to her disability. The employee who had 37 years with the company, was dismissed in August 2022 after a lengthy recovery from back surgery.

 

The employee, who underwent a routine procedure in February 2021, experienced unexpected complications that left her with significant mobility issues, including paralysis in her right leg, leading to an extended period of sick leave.


During the hearing, WRC Adjudicator Valerie Murtagh determined that Chadwicks did not adequately assess the employee’s specific needs, which could have enabled her to continue working in a modified capacity. The company misrepresented medical advice, claiming that a company doctor deemed her unfit for a sedentary role - an assertion that the adjudicator found unsubstantiated.

 

Moreover, the ruling highlighted that Chadwicks failed to consider reasonable accommodations, such as a hybrid work model or adjusted duties, which might have allowed the employee to remain employed. The employee’s own consultant neurosurgeon supported this, stating she was capable of performing her job with modifications.

 

As part of the ruling, Chadwicks has been directed to review its policies and ensure compliance with employment equality legislation.


This case serves as a crucial reminder of the importance of accommodating employees with disabilities and the need for thorough assessments before making employment decisions.



For advice and guidance on managing disabilities and ensuring equality in the workplace, get in touch with our team of specialists at MSS – The HR People today.

 

WRC Finds No Family Status Discrimination in Roster Change Request
By Amanda Scully September 15, 2026
WRC decision highlights the importance of understanding the scope of family status and engaging with employee requests for changes to working arrangements.
Private Sector Pay Increases: The 3% to 4% Trend in 2026
By Amanda Scully September 15, 2026
Private sector pay increases are becoming more concentrated in the 3% to 4% range in 2026, despite continued economic uncertainty
Performance Management Process Done Right
By Amanda Scully September 15, 2026
Performance Management, when managed effectively, annual appraisals can be a valuable part of an company's wider performance management process
Government Supports for Employers: Funding Available When Recruiting
By Amanda Scully September 15, 2026
Employers recruiting in Ireland may be able to access a range of Government supports and financial incentives
WRC Finds Pregnancy Discrimination Following Probationary Review
By Amanda Scully August 18, 2026
A recent WRC decision highlights the importance of fair, well documented probation procedures, particularly where pregnancy or pregnancy-related illness is involved.
Record €323,000 WRC Award Highlights the Serious Risks of Whistleblower Penalisation
By Amanda Scully August 18, 2026
WRC decision has highlighted the significant consequences for employers where an employee is found to have been penalised after making protected disclosures.
Pregnancy Loss Leave Bill – Proposed New Statutory Leave for Employees
By Amanda Scully August 18, 2026
Proposed new statutory entitlement to paid leave for employees who experience pregnancy loss before 23 weeks' gestation
Can Employees Use ChatGPT at Work? What Irish Employers Should Consider
By Amanda Scully August 18, 2026
Do employees understand how AI can be used safely and appropriately in the workplace
New Retirement Age Legislation Takes Effect on 29 June 2026
By Amy Vickers July 1, 2026
The Employment (Contractual Retirement Ages) Act 2025 introduces new obligations for employers who operate a contractual retirement age below State Pension Age .
Labour Court Issues First Decision on Right to Request Remote Working
By Amanda Scully June 30, 2026
A landmark Labour Court decision reinforces that the right to request remote working, highlighting the importance of employers following the correct process.